sharing tradingview charts publicly - worth doing for feedback or just noise

[bluephoenix]

been thinking about sharing my tradingview chart analyses publicly for community feedback. but i've seen that tv public charts section is full of conflicting analysis and it's not obvious how to get useful critique rather than just random comments.

is the tradingview community useful for chart feedback or is it mostly noise? how do you get quality eyes on your analysis?

[Dean]

the general tv public feed is mostly noise - people posting technical analysis for followers not for genuine feedback. to get useful feedback you need smaller, focused communities: specific discord servers around trading styles you follow, the tradingview chat on specific pairs where active traders are discussing, or tagging specific analysts whose methodology you respect. quality feedback requires context and shared framework.

[silentcore]

the quality of feedback you get is directly related to the quality of your chart presentation. a chart with clear annotations explaining your reasoning, marked key levels, and a specific question gets better responses than an undressed chart with 'what do you think'. the effort you put into presenting your analysis signals to other serious traders that your post is worth engaging with.

[urbanlegend]

been posting charts publicly for about a year. the most useful feedback came from a few specific analysts who took time to engage substantively. found them by looking at who was commenting thoughtfully on other people's analysis in the pair forums, not at who had the most followers. a 500-follower analyst who writes detailed critique is more valuable than a 50k-follower analyst who only posts their own ideas.

[urbanfox 0]

is there value in posting your analysis even if you don't get feedback? just as a public commitment to your view?

[carterw]

yes, the public commitment has genuine value. knowing your analysis is visible to others raises the standard you hold yourself to. it's the same principle as the public journal - accountability changes behavior. the discipline of articulating your reasoning clearly enough to publish it is itself a useful skill development exercise, independent of whether anyone reads it.

[Cody]

public feed is noise. smaller focused communities for real feedback. public commitment has value even without engagement.