posting my live eurusd short here for accountability, poke holes in it
-
taking a short on eurusd, entry around a clear lower-high after the daily rejected a resistance zone, stop above the swing high, target the prior demand area roughly two to one. posting before im fully sized in so its honest. genuinely want people to poke holes in the idea, not cheer it. what am i not seeing?
-
whats your reasoning for the resistance zone being valid, is it just one prior touch or has price reacted there multiple times?
-
the structure is reasonable but check the higher timeframe before committing. a clean short setup on the 4h is a knife-catch if the daily and weekly are in a strong uptrend. also confirm theres no high-impact usd or eur news between now and your target, a short eurusd through an ecb or nfp print is a different trade than the chart alone suggests.
-
youve already entered and youre asking us to poke holes, which means youll ignore any hole that suggests closing. this isnt accountability, its seeking an audience for a decision you made. the only honest version is posting the result, not the rationale.
-
the troll is partly right that pre-committed trades resist contrary input, but theres still value: if three people independently flag the same blind spot, like ignored higher-timeframe trend, thats worth more than your single read even mid-trade. you can always reduce size or tighten the stop on genuine new information. dont defend it, just listen for repeated independent concerns.
-
on the actual trade: the two to one with a stop above a clear swing high is sound structurally. my only flag is the same as above, confirm the daily isnt trending hard against you. if the daily is neutral or rolling over, this is a clean setup. if its ripping up, youre fading strength and should size smaller.
-
one more practical hole: where exactly is your stop relative to the spread and the recent wicks. if its just barely above the swing high, a normal liquidity grab wicks you out before the move you expect. give it room beyond the obvious level so youre not stopped by the exact stop-hunt your thesis should anticipate.
-
did the higher timeframe check change anything for you, curious if the feedback shifted the trade?
-
update for the thread: daily was actually neutral-to-rolling-over so i kept the short but widened the stop above the wick cluster per the feedback. it eventually reached the first target and i closed half, trailed the rest. the higher-timeframe and stop-placement comments genuinely improved the trade. this is what a useful idea thread looks like, posting the result included.
-
credit where due, you actually posted the outcome and adjusted on feedback instead of vanishing. rarer than it should be around here.
most people only show the chart once its already green. this is how you actually learn in public.Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login