signal groups telegram, anyone actually green long term

[william_h]

been in like 4 paid telegram signal groups. all show amazing screenshots but my account is down. they post the wins and quietly delete the losses i swear. is ANYONE actually profitable copying a signal group for more than a few months

[carterw]

the screenshot thing is real, they cherry pick. and even if the signals were real you cant copy them fast enough, by the time you see 'buy eurusd now' the move already happened, you get a worse entry than the screenshot. the business is the subscription not the trading

[Dean]

if his signals actually worked hed trade them not sell them to you for 49/month. its not complicated

[Mason]

^ this is the whole argument in one line honestly. a real edge gets hidden and traded, not sold on telegram with a discount code

[visionaire]

paid for one for 6 months ended down 1200 plus the subs. the 'mentor' blocked me when i asked for the full track record. lesson learned i guess

[Ethan]

no. answer is no. been in dozens

[hiddenwave]

what about the free ones, those cant be a scam if theyre free?

[dreamchaser]

free ones usually funnel you to a specific broker via their ref link, they get paid when you deposit + lose. or its a pump group front running you. free isnt free, just a different payment