at what size does prime of prime actually become accessible and worth it
-
i understand the concept of prime of prime brokers - they aggregate liquidity from multiple tier-1 banks and offer it to clients who can't access prime brokerage directly. but all the information i find is either aimed at funds or is marketing fluff.
at what account size or volume does pop pricing actually become accessible to an individual trader? is there a realistic path from retail ecn to pop, or is there a hard minimum that effectively excludes most traders?
-
realistic floor for a pop relationship these days is around 100k-250k account equity and demonstrable monthly volume of at least a few million notional. some pop providers have lower marketed minimums but in practice the pricing you get at under 100k isn't meaningfully better than a good retail ecn. the difference becomes real around 500k+ where you start accessing the actual tier-1 bank streams.
-
i went through this transition about three years ago. the practical improvement at the time was about 0.2 pips tighter on majors and significantly better fills on size above 5 lots. below 2 lots the difference is almost imperceptible. the admin overhead of the pop relationship, monthly minimums, and more complex account structure is only worth it once you're trading at consistent size.
-
do companies like ic markets and pepperstone at the top tier already have pop-level liquidity, or is there still a meaningful step up from their best retail offering?
-
pepperstone and ic markets' raw/razor accounts are already sourcing liquidity from lps (liquidity providers) at the pop level and passing most of it through. the spread difference between their retail and a direct pop relationship is marginal for most pairs. where the gap opens is execution speed (co-located vs not), access to deeper book levels, and negotiating on the commission itself at volume.
-
agree with the above. the honest answer for most profitable retail traders is the upgrade from a market maker to a good ecn/raw account broker delivers 90% of the available improvement. the remaining 10% that direct pop access provides only matters once you're trading size that the retail venue is starting to see as a problem anyway.
-
100-250k equity minimum is the practical floor. below that a good ecn is effectively equivalent.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login