breakout strategies keep catching false breakouts, how do you filter them
-
i like trading breakouts but the false ones are killing me, price breaks the level, i enter, then it snaps right back and stops me out. the real breakouts pay well but the fakeouts bleed me between them. how do experienced breakout traders filter out the false ones, or is a certain failure rate just the cost of the style?
-
a failure rate is genuinely part of the style, you cannot filter out all fakeouts without also filtering out real breakouts, theyre the same event until they arent. but you can improve the ratio. the highest-value filter for me was waiting for a retest, let price break, then come back to the level and hold it before entering, instead of entering on the initial break. you miss the runaway breakouts that never retest, but you avoid most fakeouts. its a trade-off, fewer trades, higher quality.
-
the retest entry is the classic fakeout filter and the trade-off is exactly as described, you sacrifice the breakouts that run without looking back to gain a much better hit rate on the ones you do take. other filters that help, requiring the breakout candle to close beyond the level rather than just wick through it, and checking that the break aligns with the higher-timeframe direction. breaks against the bigger trend fail far more often. context plus a close plus a retest stacks the odds.
-
the fakeouts arent a bug youre failing to filter, theyre the market taking the obvious stops sitting just past the obvious level, which is exactly where breakout traders pile in. you keep getting caught because youre entering precisely where youre supposed to be the liquidity. the level everyone watches is the trap, not the signal.
-
the troll describes the actual mechanism behind fakeouts and its worth internalising, the stop cluster just past an obvious level is liquidity the move often grabs before reversing. that insight improves the filter, it argues for entering after the grab-and-reclaim rather than on the break, and for placing stops beyond where that liquidity sweep would reach. you can turn the fakeout mechanism from your enemy into your entry by waiting for the sweep to happen and then trading the reclaim. understand why fakeouts occur and the retest entry stops being a vague tip and becomes a logical response to a known trap.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login